Theoryland of the Wheel of Time Forums

Theoryland of the Wheel of Time Forums (http://www.theoryland.com/vbulletin/index.php)
-   Theoryland Re-Read (http://www.theoryland.com/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=58)
-   -   Finished my reread - favorite scene(s) from each book (http://www.theoryland.com/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=7130)

Res_Ipsa 07-11-2012 10:39 PM

Finished my reread - favorite scene(s) from each book
 
If you feel like listing yours, please do.

My favorite scenes, in order (NS will be first) are:

NS - Aiel saluting Lan
tEotW - Moiraine recounts Manatheran's fall
tGH - Rand becomes a blade master
tDR - Matt beating the stuffing out of Gawyn and Galad
tSR - Battle of Emond's field
tFoH - Battle for Cairhien
LoC - Dumai's Wells
aCoS - Matt in Ebou Dar (all good)
tPoD - Fedwin Morr succumbing to madness and having to be killed, very sad
WH - Matt kidnapping Tuon
CoT - Scenes where Matt is trying to figure out Tuon
KoD - Loial's marriage and subsequent taking up a long-handled axe
tGS - Rand's redemption
ToM - Rand saving Maradon; honorable mention is when Matt tells off the snakes as he is fleeing the Tower of Genji.

Kimon 07-12-2012 02:33 AM

NS - Moiraine's duel with Merean
tEotW - Rand's first encounter with Min in Baerlon
tGH - The death and redemption of Ingtar
tDR - Mat rescuing the girls in the Stone of Tear
tSR - Rand's trip through the Glass Columns
tFoH - Rand reading Moiraine's letter
LoC - Dumai's Wells
aCoS - Rand & Min meeting Caraline, and his duel w/Toram Riatin
tPoD - the assassination attempt & death of Fedwin Morr
WH - the Cleansing
CoT - Mat & Tuon was all that saved this book...
KoD - the capture of Semirhage
tGS - Rand balefiring Natrin's Barrow
ToM - Rand's meeting w/the Borderlanders; Rand in the WT

Res_Ipsa 07-12-2012 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kimon (Post 194183)
tGH - The death and redemption of Ingtar

That is definitely a great scene; when it happened again with Noal/Jain in ToM I thought of Ingtar's sacrifice. "The Light, and Shinowa!"

Tomp 07-12-2012 04:07 PM

The further I went the less I could limit myself to individual scenes.

NS - Moiraine's testing.
tEotW - Rand meeting Elaida
tGH - Rand meeting Siuan, Moiraine and Verin (including preparation with Lan). Ingtar death sequence.
tDR - Mat vs the G's. Perrin's blacksmithing scene.
tSR - So many things. Perrin in Eomends field. Rand and Mat visiting Rhuidean (whole segment is epic for many reasons). Nynaeve fighting Moghedien.
tFoH - Mat laying out plans for the battle at Cairhien. Rand and Avienda getting it on.
LoC - Nynaeve's healing of Siuan, Leane and Logain. Dumai's Wells. Egwene meeting Lan. Mat arriving in Salidar and meeting "Charlies WoT-Angels".
aCoS - Nynaeve breaking her block. Mat and Tylin. Mat and the sea folk.
tPoD - Egwene taking control of the rebel AS
WH - The cleansing and the desperate attacks by the forsaken.
CoT - Scenes with Mat.
KoD - The trolloc battle at Lord Algarin's manor and the subsequent internal dialogue Rand has with LTT. Mat.
tGS - Rand's redemption. Egwene's scenes
ToM - Rand saving Maradon. Mat, Thom and Noal rescuing Moiraine. Perrin and Galad. Mah'alleinir.

Jasin Natael 07-12-2012 08:54 PM

EOTW: Thom and the Fade in Whitebridge. And almost everything Agelmar Jagad says or does.
TGH: Barthanes' manor. The Shienarin soldiers. Nynaeve's testing
TDR: Group of thugs plus three Fades. Door bursts open. Blink. Three Fades back to back, thugs dead, two dead Aiel.
TSR: Alcair Dal. Nynaeve v Moghedien
TFOH: Morgase breaks compulsion.
LOC: The Wells.
ACOS: Toram Riatin fight.
TPOD: Long time since I read this one.
WH: Far Madding
COT: Loial and Karldin.
KOD: Band v Elbar.
TGS: Natrin's Barrow.
TOM: That Borderlands watchtower at the start. Close to my favourite moment in the series as a whole. Random borderlanders, non heroes. No channeling, no wolf senses, no luck, no ta'verenness. No DEM. They know they are going to die, and nothing can stop that. They've fought the Shadow their whole lives, and their reward is to be massacred as a footnote to the story, as a tower nobody really cares about. But they're still going to fight as best they can.

Res_Ipsa 07-13-2012 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tomp (Post 194234)
Rand and Avienda getting it on.

Working "Blue" eh Tomp?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jasin Natael (Post 194247)
TOM: That Borderlands watchtower at the start. Close to my favourite moment in the series as a whole. Random borderlanders, non heroes. No channeling, no wolf senses, no luck, no ta'verenness. No DEM. They know they are going to die, and nothing can stop that. They've fought the Shadow their whole lives, and their reward is to be massacred as a footnote to the story, as a tower nobody really cares about. But they're still going to fight as best they can.

That is a great scene, it got my mental nerd fist pumping

Ivhon 07-13-2012 04:52 PM

Reading these comments makes me realize that as much as I love the character Mat, I despise his plot line. All of Ebou Dar - from arriving at Salidar to reuniting with the Band - is one big tedious bag of annoyance to me.

I am finishing LoC on my reread and kindof dreading the next couple of months' reading.

Res_Ipsa 07-13-2012 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ivhon (Post 194304)
Reading these comments makes me realize that as much as I love the character Mat, I despise his plot line. All of Ebou Dar - from arriving at Salidar to reuniting with the Band - is one big tedious bag of annoyance to me.

I am finishing LoC on my reread and kindof dreading the next couple of months' reading.

Really? That is kind of how I feel about Perrin's plotline post Dumai's Well. I loved Matt in Ebou Dar and felt it was a good progression for how he met Tuon.

Ivhon 07-13-2012 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Res_Ipsa (Post 194310)
Really? That is kind of how I feel about Perrin's plotline post Dumai's Well. I loved Matt in Ebou Dar and felt it was a good progression for how he met Tuon.

Not much of a fan of Perrin's plotline post Dumai's Wells either - although the Slayer confrontation was pretty awesome.

I think in both cases that it is RJ's flawed ability to effectively write out gender wars from the female perspective. Nynaeve, Elayne, Tuon, Faile, Berelain and all the secondary women around them (with very few exceptions...Birgitte, for example) are mindnumbingly annoying in their trite, stereotypical male-bashing characterization. Blech.

And I start CoS tomorrow.

Res_Ipsa 07-13-2012 07:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ivhon (Post 194314)
Not much of a fan of Perrin's plotline post Dumai's Wells either - although the Slayer confrontation was pretty awesome.


I am there with you, I tended to skim-read most of Perrin's plotlines in my reread of anything past Dumai's Wells. The last hunt beginning, fighting Slayer, and forging the hammer/battle are some of the few scenes I would intensely read. The Shaido's defeat was nice but I associate that with RJ taking way too long to wrap up Perrin rescuing Faile. I might be more forgiving if it did not take four books for Perrin to stop whining about being a leader.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Ivhon (Post 194314)
I think in both cases that it is RJ's flawed ability to effectively write out gender wars from the female perspective. Nynaeve, Elayne, Tuon, Faile, Berelain and all the secondary women around them (with very few exceptions...Birgitte, for example) are mindnumbingly annoying in their trite, stereotypical male-bashing characterization. Blech.


Is there a male writer who can effectively write the battle of the sexes? I think RJ had a decent premise, neither sex can understand the other completely, but then found every excuse to rearrange skirts and lift eyebrows (he got bogged down in the little strokes, and forgot about the entire painting).

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ivhon (Post 194314)
And I start CoS tomorrow.


Jasin Natael 07-13-2012 08:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Res_Ipsa (Post 194316)

Is there a male writer who can effectively write the battle of the sexes?

Male writer? That kinda undermines your point, and is pretty sexist to boot.

Res_Ipsa 07-13-2012 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jasin Natael (Post 194318)
Male writer? That kinda undermines your point, and is pretty sexist to boot.

Ihvon said RJ was bad at the battle of the sexes. RJ was a man. I asked is there a man who is good at it? It was not a rhetorical statement. How now brown cow does that weaken my argument? Try and avoid conclusory arguments this time.

As to your sexist comment, it gets old when intemperates speak the first offended remark that comes to their mind, without bothering to understand what is actually being said or better yet presume some motivation that more accurately describes their own sad mental state than it does the accused. The word itself is meant to put the receiver on the defensive and is used by a lesser order of mind to equivocate or proffer the statement as some form of intelligent remark. The only reason it succeeds is because of the culture of political correctness within our society dictates that the use of offended words be a constant pressure that squeezes the life out of actual discussion. All of that was just a fancy way of saying feel free to ignore me from now on, as it will save you the mental anguish of knowing that Res_Ipsa spouts mean and hurtful things that make you downright sorry to be an "X" (whatever subset you are claiming umbrage for in your self-righteous crusade to relieve your self-guilt).

rand 07-14-2012 12:03 AM

tEotW: Rand and Mat's journey from Whitebridge to Caemlyn
tGH: Barthanes' party
tDR: Rand vs Ishamael
tSR: the Rhuidean scene, but there are many more in this book too
tFoH: Rand vs Rahvin (similar to the Rand vs Ishamael in tDR; I like them both)
LoC: my favorite book, so pretty much all of it. Dumai's Wells is awesome, though
aCoS: stuff in Ebou Dar: meeting the Kin, Mat thinking the beggars' big sack was for stealing his money, the gholam
tPoD: Rand's campaign against the Seanchan
WH: everything in Far Madding is pretty fun, also the Cleansing
CoT: when Perrin opens the bag and the weevils fall out. Lol jk, really it's...um...um...actually that is pretty much the most exciting scene in CoT
KoD: the Trolloc attack on the manor
tGS: lots in here too: Rand BF'ing Semi/Natrin's Barrow, Egwene, the attack on the Tower, Rand on Dragonmount
ToM: the Tower of Ghenjei

I'm probably forgetting a lot of good stuff...:(

Res_Ipsa 07-14-2012 12:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rand (Post 194328)
The gholam

. . . always bugged me. It is way too powerful of a character. I know RJ gave us some exposition when he told us that is only why a few pairs were made. Initially, it was a cool creature but then it just got old realizing that he is going to kill everyone but Matt until Matt managed to get it in the gateway.

GonzoTheGreat 07-14-2012 04:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Res_Ipsa (Post 194331)
. . . always bugged me. It is way too powerful of a character. I know RJ gave us some exposition when he told us that is only why a few pairs were made. Initially, it was a cool creature but then it just got old realizing that he is going to kill everyone but Matt until Matt managed to get it in the gateway.

Suppose that a gholam manages to kill 100 people a day, every day. That's 36,525 people a year, on average. Assume that now and then they take some time off for visiting their mother, and the six gholams together would kill about 200,000 people a year. That is a lot, but on the other hand, in a world war which kills somethings like 80% or more of the entire human population, it is not really remarkable.

So the gholam is really what it is meant to be: a specialised weapon aimed at a specific type of person.

Res_Ipsa 07-14-2012 10:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GonzoTheGreat (Post 194335)
Suppose that a gholam manages to kill 100 people a day, every day. That's 36,525 people a year, on average. Assume that now and then they take some time off for visiting their mother, and the six gholams together would kill about 200,000 people a year. That is a lot, but on the other hand, in a world war which kills somethings like 80% or more of the entire human population, it is not really remarkable.

So the gholam is really what it is meant to be: a specialised weapon aimed at a specific type of person.

I understand the point you are raising but I still think the Gholam was an over powerful bad guy. Because it was so powerful, it required that the books have a very clearly tailored "allowable" situations. In Ebou Dar it was to remain secret, in Caemlyn it was to go after Matt first, etc.

GonzoTheGreat 07-14-2012 10:22 AM

I think that in Ebou Dar, it was operating under instructions from Sammael. He gave his orders based at least in part on the experience he'd gotten in the War of the Power, when people had managed to work out ways of dealing with gholam. For all we know, balefire would actually have worked. So then the "don't draw attention, and you'll be longer useful" made sense.
Later on the gholam was commanded by Moridin, who had Mat (and Perrin) on his death list. Moridin was less interested in keeping tools after they'd achieved the results he was after, so he reasoned that losing the gholam would be acceptable, if it also got rid of Mat. If that could not be achieved, then secrecy was still of value.

Terez 07-14-2012 10:25 AM

Is there any actual indication that it was taking orders from Moridin, or are you just theorizing?

GonzoTheGreat 07-14-2012 10:34 AM

Someone gave it orders:
Quote:

Originally Posted by ToM, Chapter 9, Blood in the Air
"I've been told to kill them all," the gholam said softly. "To bring you out. The man with the mustache, the aged one who interfered last time, the little dark-skinned woman who holds your affection. All of them, unless I take you now."

It is speculation that this is Moridin, true. But then, it does seem to be good speculation.

He's on top of the Shadow heap right now, and the gholam is a very valuable resource. So he would be likely to use the gholam if he learned about its existence.
None of the other Forsaken has shown a really pressing wish to kill Mat (unless he refused to dance with them).
Moridin was on the scene when Elayne and friends left Ebou Dar, and the gholam was there too. The only other Forsaken we know about that have been there are Sammael (who has an alibi), Semirhage (who also has an alibi, and wasn't there yet), and Moghedien, who is one of Moridin's pets.

All in all, I would say that the odds are very good that the gholam was gettings its orders from Moridin.

Terez 07-14-2012 10:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GonzoTheGreat (Post 194354)
It is speculation that this is Moridin, true. But then, it does seem to be good speculation.

Someone theorized a while back that Demandred might have gained control of it. Which would make sense, as the gholam passed through Murandy, and last we heard before Verin's gateway, it was still on Mat's trail (though Mat speculated it was following Luca to Lugard instead), with no reason to believe it had gotten orders from anyone. It was hanging out in the Tarasin Palace at the same time Moridin was, but there was no indication that Moridin knew it was there. In the gholam's POV, it came across the residue of Moridin's True Power weaving and was not quite able to remember what that feeling was. And then he ate the body of the man Moridin had killed.

Quote:

None of the other Forsaken has shown a really pressing wish to kill Mat (unless he refused to dance with them).
Demandred has taken an active interest in the Band, though. A smart thing for a Great Captain to do, you must admit.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:56 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.